Ireland’s Pro Pesticide Position at odds with its Greenwashed Image

7th October 2016
Press Release

Ireland is one of 18 member states who have moved to block a ban on pesticides in Ecological Focus Areas [1]. The move echoes the efforts in 2013 of the then Minister for Agriculture Simon Coveney to block a ban on pesticides within the EU linked to collapses in bee populations in Europe [2]. Despite the expensive marketing of Irish agriculture as a leader in sustainable food and drink production under Bord Bia’s Origin Green [3] initiative it is clear that Irish government remains as backward as ever when it comes to environmental issues.

Ecological Focus Areas were introduced as part of the ‘Greening' of the EU’s Common Agricultural Policy (CAP) under the 2013 CAP reform [4]. The need to reduce the environmental impact of agriculture in Europe came with the recognition that the intensification of agriculture, which was driven in the main by EU policies and subsidies had seriously degraded the environment in Europe, driving biodiversity loss and water pollution [5, 6, 7]. The CAP has a budget of 58 billion Euro a year, which accounts for about 40% of the EU’s total budget [8]. Under ‘greening’ it was agreed that 30% of EU countries' direct payment budgets or 12 billion euro a year would be reserved for certain practices aimed at addressing biodiversity loss, avoiding crop monoculture and securing carbon sequestration [4].

One of the key proposals under greening was the introduction of Ecological Focus Areas (EFA’s) on large arable farms. The scale and intensity of fertiliser and pesticide use in the EUs arable farming sector had resulted in extensive biodiversity loss, water pollution and soil degradation in many parts of Europe [9]. To try to redress this Europe’s farmers were obliged under greening to dedicate a minimum of 5% of their arable spaces to EFAs. These EFA’s range from areas where land is left fallow, to landscape features such as hedgerows, trees, buffer strips, afforested and agro-forestry areas, and measures such as catch crops and winter green cover. The idea was that these areas would be free of intensive land use, free of pesticides and fertilisers so that there would be space for wildlife to live and for essential natural processes such as pollination, soil formation and water purification to take place. It was envisioned that these EFAs would form essential environmental infrastructure from the farm to the landscape level.

Unfortunately the ambition of the EFAs was critically undermined by the successful lobbying of agribusiness lobbyists who convinced agricultural ministers of 23 Member States (including Ireland) to send a letter to the Commission to allow the use of pesticides and fertilisers in EFAs [10]. The Commission caved under pressure and left the banning of pesticides in EFA’s to the discretion of the individual EU states. The Irish government not surprisingly did not ban the use of pesticides and fertilisers in EFA’s leaving us with the incomprehensible situation where billions of taxpayers’ money are being invested in farm level protected areas which can be sprayed with herbicides to kill all plant life and sprayed with pesticides that destroy all insect life.

Environmental groups such as An Taisce have been urging the European Commission to address this abhorrent situation and place an outright ban on inputs in EFA’s so that they can deliver the environmental benefits which EU citizens have paid for. The establishment of EFA’s which are capable of supporting life is the bare minimum that should be expected from a reform which promised a "greener and fairer” CAP. In response the European Commission (EC) has put forward proposals to amend the greening provisions under CAP, including ban on the use of herbicides and pesticides in EFA’s. In response to this progressive move a delegation of 18 countries including Ireland have sent a joint statement to the European Commission ahead of an agriculture Council meeting on Monday calling on the amendment to be dropped [11].

Fintan Kelly, Natural Environment Officer, An Taisce said: “Despite the rhetoric and the expensive Origin Green advertising it is clear that nothing has changed when it comes to the Irish governments attitude to the environment. Successive Irish Agricultural Ministers have cemented our position as one of the most toxic countries in the European Union when it comes to the environment. Ireland has consistently sought to undermine any move which would address the impact of pesticides on wildlife and reduce the environmental impact of arable farming in the EU. To be clear in 2015 €364,500,900.00 will be handed to Irish farmers for greening measures which the Irish government intends to render meaningless [12]. Large arable farmers will be handed taxpayers money based solely on the amount of land they own and thanks to the government they will be given millions of euros in environmental payments for strips of land that can be sprayed with chemicals so that they support no life. This is an insult to us all”

ENDS

Contact: Fintan Kelly, Natural Environment Officer, An Taisce, The National Trust for Ireland fintan.kelly@antaisce.org

References 1 https://www.parlament.gv.at/PAKT/EU/XXV/EU/11/72/EU_117287/imfname_10659454.pdf 2 http://www.thejournal.ie/bee-neonicotinoids-ireland-eu-vote-877866-Apr2013/ 3 http://www.origingreen.ie/ 4 http://ec.europa.eu/agriculture/direct-support/greening/index_en.htm 5 http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0167880905005360 6 http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S016788090600079X 7 http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0301479709002448 8 http://ec.europa.eu/agriculture/cap-funding/pdf/cap-spending-09-2015_en.pdf 9 http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0301479701904736 10 http://www.pan-europe.info/press-releases/2014/03/pesticides-use-ecological-focus-areas-delegated-acts-common-agricultural 11 https://www.parlament.gv.at/PAKT/EU/XXV/EU/11/72/EU_117287/imfname_10659454.pdf 12 https://www.agriculture.gov.ie/media/migration/publications/2014/CAP2015AnIntroductiontoDirectPayments260314.pdf