An Taisce Ezine Volume 6 Issue 4

1st April 2014
Volume 6 Issue 4

An Taisce obtains leave for Appeal on Hinkley Point legal challenge

27th March 2014

An Taisce - the National Trust for Ireland - today successfully obtained leave to take its Hinkley Point legal challenge to the Court of Appeal in London

At the end of a brief hearing in London this morning, An Taisce - the National Trust for Ireland - was granted leave to take its legal challenge regarding Hinkley Point C nuclear power station to the Court of Appeal. The case is likely to be heard before the end of the summer.

An Taisce argues that the UK government's decision to approve Hinkley Point C nuclear plant (on England's west coast) without first consulting the public in Ireland is contrary to international, EU and English law.

The High Court in London found against An Taisce's arguments in December 2013, ruling that there was no need to consult the public in Ireland in the circumstances.

However, earlier this month a UN Committee wrote to the UK government - having first considered the High Court's judgment and other evidence – stating that in failing to consult its neighbours, Hinkley Point raises "a profound suspicion of non-compliance" with international law (the Espoo Convention on Environmental Impact Assessment in a Transboundary Context).

This letter - on foot of a complaint to the Espoo Convention's Implementation Committee by Friends of the Irish Environment – provided strong support for the arguments advanced in An Taisce's legal challenge.

In light of this letter and An Taisce's arguments, Sullivan LJ concluded today that leave to take the case to the Court of Appeal should indeed be granted, overturning an earlier decision on the papers.

Commenting on today's decision, An Taisce's Natural Environment Officer and In-house solicitor Andrew Jackson said, "We've always felt we have a very strong case, even following the High Court's decision. We look forward to airing our arguments before the Court of Appeal. It's important to remember that this case is not about being pro or anti-nuclear. It's about the public's right to participate in decisions which could affect their lives - fundamental environmental democratic rights which are underpinned by international and EU law."

He continued, "We must thank our excellent legal team: Leigh Day solicitors and barristers David Wolfe QC and John Kenny BL. Credit is also due to Friends of the Irish Environment for their excellent work before the Espoo Convention's Implementation Committee. This is an important public interest case and we trust that the public's rights will ultimately be vindicated."

Notes:

The Espoo Convention Implementation Committee's letter to the UK government is here: http://www.friendsoftheirishenvironment.org/cmsfiles/Library/Committee-letter-19.03.14.pdf

The hearing is set for July 15 th and 16 th

Report from the Agri-Environment Office

1st April 2014

It has been another interesting month in the world of Irish agriculture and An Taisce have been in the thick of it. We have been working hard to communicate the environmental implications of the government’s Food Harvest 2020 plan and are in the midst of making a proposal to government on below cost selling.

Most noteworthy was James Nix’s appearance on Prime Time where he debated with Minister for Agriculture, Simon Coveney, on the pros and cons of FH2020. James got some strong points across including the inevitable increase in GHG emissions, the continuation of a debt based farming model, in which farmers are required to use their property as collateral, and the vulnerability that will come with an increased dairy herd. Despite the disagreements between An Taisce and the Department of Food Agriculture and the Marine it was an excellent opportunity to engage directly with the Minister on a national platform.

James Nix and Jack McCarthy were invited by Dr. Cara Augustenborg to deliver a lecture to UCD MSc. students on the contradictions between Food Harvest 2020 and achieving Ireland’s Greenhouse Gas reduction goals. Meaningful engagement took place between James, Jack, and the students in attendance. The lecture aimed to dismantle the justifications of what is, ultimately, a climatically irresponsible programme. The students gave many valuable suggestions. The aim now is to develop the presentation to bring to a wider audience.

Finally, An Taisce have been making some ripples in the media with a press release that calls on the government to legislate for retailers to display the price paid to farmers for certain produce, or a Primary Produce Amount. The proposed legislation would see the big five (Dunnes, Supervalu/centra, Tesco, Lidl, and Aldi) required to display the price paid to farmers next to the sales price. We believe that this will contribute to increasing consumer awareness and ultimately a better price for farmers producing fruit, vegetables and other products. The pre-Christmas price wars have shown that there is appetite for such a change.

Links

http://www.rte.ie/player/ie/show/10277792/ Prime Time debate

http://www.antaisce.org/WhatsNow/News/AnTaisceamp;RelatedNewsReleases/tabid/262/articleType/ArticleView/articleId/1333/Legislate-for-large-retailers-to-display-the-amount-they-pay-to-farmers.aspx - Press release on Primary Producer Amount

An Bord Pleanála grants expenses

1st April 2014

For the first time An Bord Pleanála‎ has awarded a planning appellant expenses under Section 145 Planning and Development Act 2000 in a case to be paid by Galway County Coucil to the appellant.

One of the most unfair features of the Irish planing system is the manner in which anyone taking an appeal to An Bord Pleanála and securing the overturn of an inappropriate local authority decision, may have to deal with a repeat application and permission grant by the local Council and bear the cost of a second or more appeals.

Although there is a Provision under Section 145 Planing and Development Acts 2000 by which An Bord Pleanála can require the local authority to pay the appellant for the expenses of the appeal, the Board has until recently consistency refused expenses applications

However An Bord Pleanála has for the first time granted third party costs of an appeal to an appellant in a case in Co Galway withing the last month. The Board in refusing a repeat application for the retention of unauthorized development of larges gate piers and gates at a highly sensitive coastal location at Keeraun Beg, Carroroe Galway Co Co ref 12/1394 An Bord Pleanála re 242436 ref granted expenses to the local appellant who was represented by Peter Sweetman

An identical retention application has previously been refused by the Board Galway Co Co ref 11/777 Board ref 239355. The the grounds of refusal of on the previous retention application were:

  1. ‘The site is located in a scenic coastal area that is classified as an area of high landscape value in the Galway County Development Plan, 2009-2015. The development plan also contains policies to protect the amenity of the coastal zone, including the protection of the character of boreens that lead to the foreshore. Having regard to the pattern of development in the area, and to the excessive scale and design of the pillars and gates proposed for retention, it is considered that the proposed development, would be out of character with the pattern of development in the area, would seriously injure the amenities of the area and would conflict with the policies of the said development plan. Furthermore, it is considered that to permit the development would set an undesirable precedent for proliferation of other similar entrance features that would cumulatively erode the character of the landscape in the area. The proposed development would, therefore be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.

  2. The Galway County Development Plan, 2009-2015 includes a policy to:

prohibit the intrusion of development along public walking routes and public rights of way. On the basis of the information submitted, the Board is not satisfied that the proposed development, owing to the location of the piers and gates for which retention permission is sought, would not interfere with orderly access to the nearby public pier and would not interfere with the safety and convenience of road users at this location. The proposed development would constitute a disorderly approach to development, would conflict with the policies of the said development plan, and would, be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area’.

While this case did not relate to a large scale development it is significant in location sensitivity and the strong terms of the An Bord Pleanala refusal on the first and second retention applications. The manner in which Galway County County Council accommodated a repeat retention application for the retention of this unauthorised development raises the most profound questions on its competence as planning authority.

This case should encourage appellants to more actively pursue expenses recovery in future An Bord Pleanála refusals.

Ian Lumley

An Taisce, Kerry Association

1st April 2014

County Kerry is now getting ready to set up the new structures required under the Local Government Reform Act 2014. We have been active with the Community and Voluntary Sector in making people aware of the changes about to take place. The county-wide 15 member Local Community Development Committee (LCDC) is being established at present and An Taisce has been offered a temporary position on it. Our function would be to represent the Environmental and Heritage Organisations in the county. We are, at present, arranging through the Community & Voluntary Forum to contact all the organisations in the county that come under this heading. Environmental Representatives will be needed on the Public Participation Networks for each of the four Municipal areas in the county from which other committees, such as Strategic Policy Committees will be filled.

Other Environmental News

11th April 2014

Time for a clearer vision of justice, rights and the environment For more information click here

An ethical look at climate change For more information click here

Tell MEP candidates to take action on climate change For more information click here

INTO - International National Trusts Organisation For more information click here

Naomi Klein - Climate change is the fight of our lives – yet we can hardly bear to look at it For more information click here

Irish Times - Buildings at Risk For more information click here

Lough Derg White Tailed Sea Eagles For more information click here

Years of Living Dangerously and Sand Wars For more information click here

Japan for Sustainability (or Sustainability for Japan) For more information click here

EU Consultation Notice on Ecolabels For more information click here

Meath Association Monthly Report

29th April 2014

The Meath Association AGM took place on Tuesday 29 th April at 7:30 pm in Slane Castle. The meeting was preceded by a talk by Alex Earl of Mount Charles on the ‘Proposed Distillery at Slane’.

The Ellison Awards for 2014 will be launched at the AGM. An information sheet is attached and further details can also be obtained by emailing ellisonaward2014@gmail.com. The closing date for nominations is 5 pm Friday 5 th May 2014. See the Ellison Awards 2014– Information Sheet.

This year properties from county Louth are included. The award ceremony will take place on Saturday 1 st November in Killeen Castle, Dunsany and Mary-Rose Carty, main author of ‘Killeen Castle’ will give a talk on the history of the castle and the family who built it.

The date of the Boyne walk at Oldbridge estate has been changed from the 17 th of May to Saturday 10 th May. The event will start with a picnic (self-provided) on the grounds of Oldbridge house. John Ducie will then give a guided tour to the Glenmore section of the Boyne navigation, along which he will identify and discuss the various habitats. All are welcome to attend and view one of An Taisce’s finest trust properties and the new Greenway. Please be advised to wear comfortable walking shoes and bring rain gear just in case the weather is unfavourable.

The Boyne Navigation Group work party have completed the steps at the retaining wall on the Sealock and the paving is nearly complete despite delays due to the construction of the Boyne Greenway. There will be an opening day later in the summer and we will keep members informed. The BNG are also now casting their minds on restoration of the Turf Lock at the Horse Bridge.

Clare Association Report

29th April 2014

The Clare Association has been busy with the "Government Reconstruction" as well as new thinking on our Burren Land. The local members in Clare are interest in the Public Participation aspect of the future system and our secretary is on a working group setting up the "Plenary" which will eventually be the Environmental Electoral College of the Public Participation Network mainly sure that the public in future will be engaged in policy making about the environment.

James Nix's letter in the Financial Times

29th May 2014

A forked approach to collective action

A letter from An Taisce's director James Nix featured today (29th May) in the Financial Times.

Sir, The EU should become a single purchaser for gas, suggests Donald Tusk, Poland’s prime minister (“Europe should unite to break Moscow’s grip on gas”, April 22). Mr Tusk also argues that “Europe should make full use of the fossil fuels available, including coal and shale gas”, adding that nations should not be prevented if they want to “extract minerals”.

In buying gas, Mr Tusk likes collective action. But to maintain climate stability, he doesn’t like collective action at all, contending, essentially, that greater flexibility for fossil fuel use should take precedence over maintaining our environment.

How bewildering this stance is: to ease the short-term threat of being cold over the winter months, the EU should act together. But to minimise the medium and long-term threat to the reasonably stable climate we have enjoyed for tens of thousands of years, he weighs in against the collective EU approach.

In outlining his ideas, Mr Tusk refers to the solidarity shared by the founding fathers of the European Union who laid the foundations for today’s EU with the establishment of the European Coal and Steel Community in 1952.

If they saw Mr Tusk’s plan to cherrypick Europe’s capacity for collective action, those same founding fathers would likely take little comfort in such a forked attitude to solidarity.

James Nix, Policy Director, An Taisce – The National Trust for Ireland, Dublin 8, Ireland

Public Participation Networks

31st May 2014

Public Participation Networks are being rolled out across the country as the primary means of Civic Society to engage with County Councils at the Municipal Area and County/City Level.

This has been evolving since February - and is not yet fully tied down. (For instance the number of Environmental Reps on the LCDC) but it finally looks like it will be implemented.

There is specific involvement of 'Environmental' groups, such as An Taisce.

If you are an An Taisce member and you would be willing to get involved with your local PPPN (Public Participation Network) you should:

Contact Eoin Heaney info@antaisce.org and advise him of your willingness to be involved. Keep an eye on your local press/County Website for details of what they are doing to set-up the PPN's in your County. If possible attend a 'Road Show' on Public Participation Networks - see details of Cork Event above - there will be others. Come to the AGM, where a session in the afternoon will try and explain it all to you. We will arrange to support you to the best of our abilities - which will be tough as this is being rushed by the Government

GUIDELINES FOR PUBLIC PARTICIPATION NETWORKS

To be established in each Local Authority by June 1 st, 2014.

Effective April 2014 until further notice

1.1 Framework for Public Engagement and Participation

A new framework for public engagement and participation, to be called “The Public Participation Network (PPN)” will be developed within each local authority area (engaging in and within municipal districts and at the County/City level) to enable the public to take an active formal role in the policy making and oversight activities of the Local Authority’s areas of responsibility including those outlined in appendix 2 below.

The PPN will be the main link through which the local authority connects with the community, voluntary and environmental sectors without prejudice to other consultation processes.

The aim of the structures and processes is to facilitate and enable the public and the organisations to articulate a diverse range of views and interests within the local government system, not to reduce or homogenise this diversity. A parallel and equally important aim should be to facilitate the local authority in making better and more timely decisions. To allow the diversity of voices and interests to be facilitated and involved in decision-making, a network should be set up in each county/city and municipal district.

Members of the local community interact with local government at different levels. The PPN facilitates input by the public into local government through a structure that ensures public participation and representation on decision-making committees and bodies within local government.

All individuals may access local government through the existing arrangements in regard to their issues. For the purpose of this structured public participation within local government, individuals may join an existing group or organisation or they can establish an interest group or organisation and register it with the PPN.

The Network:

Facilitates the participation and representation of communities in a fair, equitable and transparent manner through the environmental, social inclusion & voluntary sectors on decision making bodies Strengthens the capacity of communities and of the environmental, social inclusion, community & voluntary groups to contribute positively to the community in which they reside/participate Provides information relevant to the environmental, social inclusion & voluntary sector and acts as a hub around which information is distributed and received. In particular the role of the Network is:

To contribute to the local authority’s development for the County/City a vision for the well-being of this and future generations. to facilitate opportunities for networking, communication and the sharing of information between environmental, community and voluntary groups and between these groups and the local authority. to identify issues of collective concern and work to influence policy locally in relation to these issues. to actively support inclusion of socially excluded groups, communities experiencing high levels of poverty, communities experiencing discrimination, including Travellers to enable them to participate at local and county level and to clearly demonstrate same. to encourage and enable public participation in local decision making and planning of services. to facilitate the selection of participants from the environmental, social inclusion and voluntary sectors onto city/county decision making bodies. to support a process that will feed the broad range of ideas, experience, suggestions and proposals of the Network into policies and plans being developed by agencies and decision makers in areas that are of interest and relevant to the Network to work to develop the Environmental, Social Inclusion, Community and Voluntary sectors so that the work of the sectors is clearly recognised and acknowledged and the sectors have a strong collective voice within the County/City. to support the individual members of the Public Participation Network so that: They can develop their capacity and do their work more effectively. They can participate effectively in the Public Participation Network activities. They are included and their voices and concerns are heard. 1.2 Key Principles of Working

The Public Participation Network will

Implement and abide by good governance structures. One way of doing this would be by adopting the ‘Governance Code for Community, Voluntary and Charitable Organisations’. Work in an inclusive, respectful, transparent and collaborative manner. Act as the vehicle to gather feedback and input into policies and plans being developed by local authorities, reflecting both areas of disagreement and, where there is no consensus, the range of views. The Public Participation Networks must operate in a manner that recognises that the sectors are broad and made up of people with many different opinions. It is not expected that the Public Participation Networks will come up with a ‘one voice response’ but that it will feed back the issues and suggestions raised by a broad range of environmental, community and & voluntary groups. It is recognised that where contradictory responses are presented to the local authority, the ultimate responsibility for resolving these in the finalisation of policies will rest with the elected members.

  1. Public Participation Network (PPN) Structures

2.1 Outline of structure

The Public Participation Network (PPN) will be organised:

At County/City level At Municipal District level Each PPN will have:

A County/City Plenary at County/City level which deals with county/city level issues A Municipal District Plenary in each Municipal District which deals with issues at a municipal level Linkage Groups which deal with specific issues A secretariat at county/City level that is a facilitation and communication mechanism. Details on these structures are provided below.

2.2 Municipal District PUBLIC PARTICIPATION NETWORK (PPN)

Under the Local Government Reform Act 2014, each county is divided into Municipal Districts.

Each Municipal District will have a Public Participation Network (PPN). This is made up of community, voluntary and environmental organisations within the Municipal District. These organisations work together on agreed objectives based on promoting the well-being of this and future generations. Where the local authority would find operation of the Network as sub-Municipal District level advantageous, this can be provided for.

2.2.1 Municipal District Plenary

The Plenary is the ruling body of the Municipal District PPN and is made up of all registered community, environmental and voluntary organisations in the District.

Each Member Organisation will have one vote. They may select two people to represent them on Plenary of the Municipal District PPN. One of these people will be the main Representative and the other the Alternate .

The plenary of each Municipal District PPN will meet formally at least twice a year. The initial meeting in year one will be convened by the County/City Council after which the Municipal District PPN makes its own arrangements.

Each Municipal District PPN will commence its work by going through a process to set out what it considers necessary to promote well-being for present and future generations.

The PPN in each Municipal District has the freedom to engage as it sees fit in whatever way it wishes to promote local development and in this way it can harness local capacity and strengthen local development in a very real manner.

The Plenary of each Municipal District PPN nominates one person to the Secretariat for the County/City PPN.

Member organisations of the Municipal District PPN may also be members of the City/County PPN.

In order for the Network to work effectively, it is recommended that there is one County Register for all environmental, voluntary and social inclusion groups, a copy of which will be maintained by the local authority in accordance with Section 128 of the Local Government Act 2001.

All groups must be registered by an agreed date in any given year, in order to have voting rights in the following year.

Network registration forms should be completed annually by organisations in the Public Participation Networks (PPN).

2.3 County/City PPN:

All registered organisations in the County/City are members of the County/City PPN. The PPN will be the main channel through which people will be selected to participate in various processes of the County/City Councils and their Boards/Committees.

Participants will be chosen by the PPN and should not be rejected by the County Council or any of its structures. Likewise, the Council or its structures should not bypass the PPN in choosing representatives from the social inclusion, environmental or voluntary sectors to sit on any of its Boards/Committees.

2.3.1 County/City Plenary

At a county level the Plenary is the ruling body of the PPN

Member organisations are represented on the Plenary of the County/City PPN.

The County/City PPN Plenary will meet formally at least twice a year. The first meeting in year 1 will be organised by the Local Authority after which the County/City PPN Plenary will make its own arrangements.

Each Member Organisation will have one vote. They may select two people to represent them on the Plenary. One of these people will be the main Representative and the other the Alternate.

A Plenary Meeting shall be deemed a valid meeting if at least 15% of the Member Organisations are represented and also only if at least 4 of those present are members of the Secretariat. There must also be an automatic and guaranteed 21 days’ notice of the meeting.

2.4 Secretariat

Each City/County PPN will have a Secretariat whose role is to

Facilitate the implementation of the decisions of the Plenary Ensure the proper functioning of the PPN in between Plenaries Coordinate activities of PPN Communicate extensively and regularly with all PPN members and in this process disseminate information concerning all PPN activities as widely as possible Manage the resource worker who will be provided to PPN at a county level to enable them in delivering their objectives The Secretariat will meet at least four times a year.

The Secretariat will be made up of:

one representative nominated from each of the Municipal District PPNs An equal number of representatives from each of the electoral colleges of the PPN, i.e. Community, Social Inclusion, and Environment. The minimum should be two from each. The Secretariat should be provided with an office and have a resource worker. There should be provision for agenda-setting, including of matters of importance to the local authority.

2.5 Linkage Groups

The Linkage Group mechanism is central to ensuring that:

All member organisations are enabled to participate in shaping the decisions that affect them that are being developed by any structure of the County/City Council. All member organisations play a direct role in choosing their participants in County/City Council structures addressing particular issues. The views of all those involved will be communicated within the relevant County/City structure. All member organisations will be fully up to date with developments in all of these County/City structures. This is how the Linkage Groups work.

When the County/City Council has public participant seats to fill on any of its committees/structures it will notify the PPN Secretariat and ask that the representatives to fill these seats be chosen by the PPN. The Secretariat will then Notify ALL member organisations in the County/City of this situation, and Arrange a time and place for a meeting of all those organisations with an interest/involvement in the issue(s) being addressed by the particular body or, in the case of places representing particular interests of communities, those organisations which fit the relevant criteria. This group will constitute a PPN ‘Linkage Group’ for this particular body and the topic(s) being addressed.

The Linkage Group will choose their representative(s) for the body. The person(s) chosen to represent the PPN in such bodies will meet their Linkage Group regularly. The Linkage Group should operate as their reference group on the issues arising. They will report back to the Linkage Group after every meeting. They will take direction from the Linkage Group on the positions they are to take on particular issues. Each representative taking up such a position for the PPN must

Represent the views of all the members of the Linkage Group and not just those of their own organisation. Abide by the communications protocols set out above.

Diagram to show the relationship between the Public Participation Network Structures and Local Government Bodies - The arrows indicate nominating rights of the different bodies. This is just an example, there may be more than three Municipal Districts.

2.6 ELECTIONS of PPN Representatives for various bodies

In all elections of PPN representatives, care will be taken to ensure:

Gender balance Geographical spread of representatives All nominations are formally ratified at the Plenary meeting of PPN.

2.6.1 Electoral Colleges

Member Organisations when joining the PPN at a county level must opt to be a part of one of three electoral colleges within the PPN:

Environment Social Inclusion Voluntary To join the environment Electoral College an organisation’s primary objectives and activities must be environmental (i.e. ecological) protection and/or environmental sustainability. Membership of this Electoral College will be validated by the Environmental Pillar at a national level.

To join the Social Inclusion Electoral College an organisation’s primary objectives and activities must focus on social inclusion / social justice / equality.

Organisations whose primary objectives are other than those listed above will be members of the Voluntary Electoral College.

Each of these three Electoral Colleges

Chooses an equal number of people (but not less than two) to represent them on the PPN Secretariat. Elects members from among their own college members to represent them on the County’s Local Community Development Committee. In this respect, 5 members are to be nominated to the LCDC from the PPN (two from the Community and Voluntary College, two from the Social Inclusion College and one from the Environment College).

2.6.2 Criteria to guide choosing of PPN representatives to any bodies

The following criteria will apply in making the decision about who to nominate:

The track record of the nominee in working on the issue that is the focus for the representative forum. The ability of the nominee to make an effective contribution. The participation of people experiencing the problem/issue to be addressed at the representative forum. Whether the problem/issue to be addressed at the forum is a ‘core issue’ for the PPN member. As far as possible ensuring fair distribution of positions across geographical areas. As far as possible ensuring gender balance. A commitment from the person(s) to operate the linkage arrangements set out below. In addition to the above, the following generic requirements must be met:

Elected representatives of Local Authorities cannot be nominated through this process. If anyone nominated through this process subsequently decides to enter electoral politics he/she must immediately resign their PPN representative role and the relevant nominating PPN unit (Electoral College / Linkage Group) will choose a replacement. A person who has been an elected representative of any level of Government (local or national) should not be chosen to represent PPN in any representative role for one year after completing their term of office. Employees/professionals, where there is a conflict of interest, cannot be nominated. All PPN representatives must meet the criteria laid down by the unit that nominates them to their representative role. 2.7 Representing the PPN

The nominees are required to represent the PPN and are accountable to the PPN membership. They are not representing their own organisation.

Specifically the role of the representative is to

Bring issues of relevance from the body that chose them to the policy making arena. Give feedback to their Linkage Group, Electoral College and/or Plenary as appropriate on the outcomes of the policy meetings and the issues being raised. 2.8 Facilitating two-way communication in the Network

In order for the Network structure to meet its objectives, it is critical that the representatives from the PPN actively give and seek feedback from its membership. It is therefore critical that appropriate dialogue structures are developed to facilitate this engagement, keep its membership up to date on work being progressed and gather information in relation to issues of concern by its broader membership. It is therefore recommended that for the Network:

A representative’s charter should be agreed Feedback forms/mechanisms should be agreed and must be completed by all representatives Web/social media mechanisms should be developed to communicate with the wider Network. This would include putting Agendas and agreed meeting notes up on the web for all structures and sub structures of the Network Newsletters should focus on feeding back and seeking feedback from / to the membership of the Network Specific consultation workshops should be held for particularly significant plans/policies. These could be organised by the Network in order to gather the ideas/suggestions of the wider environmental, community and voluntary sector Updates on all aspects of the work should be provided at Plenary meetings Opportunities for PPN members to feed into plans/policies that might be relevant to them should be highlighted 2.9 Promoting Well-being

According to a study by the National Economic and Social Council (NESC) “a person’s well-being relates to their physical, social and mental state. It requires that basic needs are met, that people have a sense of purpose, and that they feel able to achieve important goals, to participate in society and to live the lives they value and have reason to value.” [1] A society’s well-being requires that economic, political, environmental, cultural and social developments all be sustainable. It also requires a focus on inter-generational justice to ensure the well-being of future generations is promoted.

As noted already, the County/City Plenary and the Municipal District Plenary of the PPN will commence their work by going through a process to set out what they consider necessary to promote well-being for present and future generations. This process begins at Municipal District level. Such a statement may also be developed by other units of the PPN structure (e.g. Linkage Groups) if they wish to do so.

This statement will act as a guiding vision statement for everything done by the group that drew up the statement e.g. choosing representatives, taking positions on issues, developing activities of any kind etc.

Well-being statements should be reviewed by the PPN bi-annually.

2.10 Benefits to groups in joining a Network

Only those groups who are members of the Network may nominate individuals to sit on Boards/Committees as Network participants/representatives Receipt of regular information which highlights and promotes the work of the Network and the activities of its members Receipt of information on opportunities to learn about and feed into policy and plans that may be relevant to the group May be part of a Linkage Group which meets directly and regularly with those representing the PPN on various County Boards/Committees dealing with issues of concern to the particular member organisation. Receipt of and submission of information / being part of a communications system managed by the Network Vote as an organisation to elect members on the countywide Secretariat Participate in training courses and workshops organised by the Network that support the development of the sectors involved and their representation on decision making bodies Engage in the wide variety of activities organised by the Network Can be elected on to policy making bodies in the city/county. Member groups can be part of a collective voice. 2.11 Interaction of the Network with the Local Authority (LA) on LA Committees

The expectation of the Local Authority from the Network representatives is that they will bring the knowledge and expertise of this sector with them and ensure that any policy developed has taken into consideration their needs. It is expected that this should foster a higher degree of community relevance and local participation.

The LA will have a duty of care to ensure that the network is supported so that it can achieve its objective/purpose.

The expectation of the PPN representatives from the Local Authority is that Local Authorities will recognise their right and responsibilities in these areas. They will also have to ensure that engagement with the public really is participative. For appropriate participation of the public, user-friendly and easily accessible structures and processes are required.

2.12 Network Meetings

A timeline for Network Meetings across the county should be agreed annually so as to maximise inter-network collaborative working.

Care must be taken by both the Local Authority and the PPN to facilitate as far as possible the participation of volunteers who are not in a position to attend meetings during office hours.

Attendance at meetings should be monitored for the purpose of identifying problems with the process and structure. In the event of non-attendance for three consecutive Network meetings by an organisational representative, a meeting should be sought between the organisation and Network Facilitator and / or Chair to seek a resolution. If no resolution can be found, a replacement representative should be sought.

2.13 Feedback structures – re representative on decision making structures

Feedback mechanisms should be agreed and must be completed by all representatives Representatives charter should be agreed As well as meeting regularly with the relevant Linkage Group each person representing the PPN in any arena should complete a report of each meeting for circulation to the Linkage Group and to all others in the Network.

2.14 Supports Necessary to Make the Network Effective

Direct support for the Network should be provided by dedicated staff from the Local Authority with the support of Local Development structures where appropriate.

2.14.1 State Supports necessary to make the Network effective

Government and the local authorities need to play their part in ensuring that the community, voluntary and environmental sectors can actively and positively engage with its decision making forums. The following actions are suggested:

Local Authorities to agree and adopt a Protocol for all committees/decision making committees with PPN representatives which will enable the representatives to engage appropriately Local Authorities to set aside resources for participation on key decision making committees to cover travel and subsistence expenses for PPN representatives Local Authorities to facilitate access to a library of relevant thematic documents focused on groups and committees that the Network are represented on Local Authorities to provide for one whole time equivalent staff member for the Network. It is essential that this resource is funded on an on-going basis so that the capacity of the development /coordination position is built upon and relationships with the community, voluntary and environmental sectors are developed on an on-going basis. Local Authorities to provide programme funding for all Networks which would allow them to Roll out their annual programme of activity Roll out minimum of 4 newsletters per year develop web site/social media tools Provide training supports for public Participants / Representatives Local Authorities to provide additional resources to enable effective participation in these structures. In particular, care should be taken to resource those who are most vulnerable and/or whose voices are least heard. 2.15Training Supports that may be required for Representatives to enable them build their capacity for the role of PPN Representative.

Training supports should include:

induction pack for new committee members An induction meeting to brief a new member should take place prior to the first policy making meeting If a key policy/plan is being developed, a workshop with key information on the policy/plan should be organised to build capacity of community to feed into the policy/plan Non-technical summaries of the main points of technical documents should be made available to all members of committees Technical mentors should be sought on a voluntary basis initially to enable all members to fully understand technical issues and to aid decision-making The Network’s administration support should include office accommodation with a library of relevant documents available to representatives focused on the thematic groups they are represented on. Networks should organise guest speakers and workshops in relation to current topical areas /policies and plans to ensure members are kept up to date and informed on key national and local policies and plans. Network will work with other agencies in the county to develop a specific training plan for representatives that could include topics such as committee skill, advocacy, facilitation skills etc. The Network will give priority to training, up-skilling and enabling volunteers. 2.16 Oversight, Monitoring and Evaluation

The work of the PPN will be monitored and evaluated regularly in line with best practice. The focus of this oversight will be an assessment of whether or not they are achieving their overall purpose of facilitating engagement with the local authority and whether the structures, systems and processes are supporting the achievement of that purpose. This could be undertaken by the National Oversight and Audit Commission (NOAC) or a small Oversight Group appointed by the Minister.

2.16.1 Indicators in relation to measuring the work of the Network

In order to provide assurance that appropriate environmental, community and voluntary structures have been developed on the ground and that they are actively supported to engage with the decision making forums of the local authority, the information listed below should be among the data collated on an annual basis as part of their work programme.

In addition, the Network will be monitored on an ongoing basis and audited at least once in the lifetime of the local authority term.

Suggested Indicators to be collated on an Annual Basis

Number of members of the Network Number of representatives on decision making bodies Number of decision making bodies that the Network is represented on Level of attendance at decision-body meetings by PPN Representatives. Level of attendance at Linkage Group meetings by PPN Representatives on decision-making bodies. Number of consultation workshop held by the Network Number of newsletters issued Number of email newsletters circulated Qualitative indicators, e.g. related to effectiveness would need to be developed Number of training supports developed or held for Network representatives Number of feedback forms completed by representatives Number of submissions made in relation to new policies/plans Number of hits on web site In this process special attention should be paid to ensuring that the views of the PPN member organisations on promoting the well-being of present and future generations in their locality are being effectively communicated by PPN representatives in all arenas in which they participate.

[1] NESC, 2009 Well-Being Matters – A Social Report on Ireland, NESC Dublin

IPCC Report – Strong emissions reduction now the only way to avoid destabilised future.

12th June 2014

Government must introduce an annual carbon budget which has a path to near-zero emissions by 2050

Today’s launch of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change’s (IPCC) latest report tells us that only rapid and sustained cuts to carbon emissions will allow us to avoid catastrophic climate change. Previous IPCC reports confirm that climate change is unequivocally caused by human activity and that the impacts of global warming, from extreme weather to reduced food production, pose a grave threat to humanity.

The problem is that human caused carbon dioxide remains in the atmosphere and will continue warming it for thousands of years. We continue to add CO 2 by burning fossil fuels. It is accumulating so quickly that without radical global reductions in carbon emissions, beginning right now, catastrophic changes to the Earth’s climate will happen within the coming decades.

Ireland must play its part in the global solution. Cross party support is needed now to push the EU for global agreements at the meeting of key negotiators in Paris next year. The Government must introduce an annual carbon budget which has a path to near-zero emissions by 2050, the decarbonisation of electricity generation by 2030 and supported by strong climate law to back up the budget approach.

To increase the odds of avoiding disastrous changes that will destabilise our futures, we must reduce emissions deeply and quickly. We are not doing so. We must start now.

Join Ireland’s Largest Ever Coastal Clean-up

30th June 2014

Keep Ireland’s beaches in ship shape!

@CleanCoasts #cleancoastsweek

Portmarnock Beach, Dublin, 30 th April: A call for volunteers to join Ireland’s largest coastal clean-up and ensure Ireland’s beaches are in ship shape was made today by An Taisce’s Clean Coasts programme. That call was echoed by rugby legend Shane Byrne, Managing Director of AWD Waste Solutions Ltd who lined out at the launch of Coca-Cola Clean Coasts Week. Clean Coasts Week 2014 takes place from May 9 th to May 18 th and members of the public are invited to jump on board to make it the biggest yet.

Speaking at the launch Annabel FitzGerald, Coastal Programmes Manager, An Taisce said: “An Taisce’s Clean Coasts programme organises hundreds of clean-ups mobilising thousands of volunteers who remove considerable quantities of marine litter from Ireland’s environment. Raising public awareness is incredibly important when it comes to reducing marine litter and Clean Coasts’ initiatives such as Coca-Cola Clean Coasts Week and #2minutebeachcleans are excellent for public participation and creating a sense of environmental responsibility. We are on course to make Clean Coasts Week 2014 Ireland’s largest coastal clean-up event ever with 100 coastal clean-ups already registered. ” She added, “We are delighted to be working with the European Environment Agency this year and ask that all our Clean Coasts groups use the Marine LitterWatch app to record what they collect”.

Clean Coasts Week was launched at Portmarnock Beach in Dublin today by Minister Fergus O’Dowd TD Minister of State at the Department of Environment, Community & Local Government. Speaking at the launch Minister O’Dowd said, “ Ireland is famous internationally for its beautiful and scenic coastline, which supports rich ecosystems and vibrant economic activity. It is enjoyed by both visitors and locals alike. Tourism initiatives such as the Wild Atlantic Way plan to highlight the unique beauty of this natural asset. The damage done by this winter’s storms, however, highlights its vulnerability. I would like to commend all who participate in this year’s Clean Coasts week as it is such an important and worthwhile endeavor to protect and enhance such a valuable resource for the current and future generations.”

Speaking at the launch, Erica Roseingrave, Public Affairs & Communications Manager, Coca-Cola Hellenic Ireland said, “The many clean-up events that take place during Coca-Cola Clean Coasts Week greatly benefit not only the local environment but also communities in which they take place. Clean-ups form a fantastic opportunity for thousands of volunteers to get out, be active and enjoy some fresh air and at the same time get to know their neighbours and make new friends. This social dimension of the Clean Coasts programme is one of its broader benefits and one of the reasons the groups are growing all the time. It’s really positive and we’re delighted to be part of it.”

What’s new during Coca-Cola Clean Coasts Week 2014?

The Marine LitterWatch App – Clean Coasts and the European Environment Agency Marine litter is recognised as a growing pressure on coastal and marine environments. It has cross border impacts on wildlife and habitats as well as on human activities and health. It is a societal problem that needs our engagement. Reflecting on the need to fill data gaps as well as the aims of involving citizens in environmental issues such as marine litter, the European Environment Agency has developed the Marine LitterWatch app. Clean Coasts will be asking those who participate in Coca-Cola Clean Coasts Week to download the app and record what they collect. Each clean-up will have a unique code to make using the app easier.

Let’s Clean Up Europe Day - May 10 th The Environmental Education Unit of An Taisce is the coordinator for Let’s Clean Up Europe Day. Marine litter is entirely due to human activity, and therefore can and has to be controlled by human management. However, one community, one NGO or one country acting in isolation will not be the answer. The problem of marine litter should be addressed collectively across national boundaries and on May 10 th Clean Coasts are delighted to be promoting Let’s Clean Up Europe Day.

Beat the Microbead Day – May 16 th Clean Coasts will be launching their Beat the Microbead awareness raising initiative on May 16 th. Microbeads are tiny particles of plastic are ingredients in thousands of personal care products sold around the world. These microbeads, hardly visible to the naked eye, flow straight from the bathroom drain into the sewage system. Wastewater treatment plants are not designed to filter out microbeads and so they end up in our oceans. Sea creatures absorb or eat microbeads. These microbeads are passed along the marine food chain. Since humans are ultimately at the top of this food chain, it is likely that we are also absorbing microbeads from the food we eat. Microbeads are not biodegradable and once they enter the marine environment, they are impossible to remove. www.beatthemicrobead.org

National #2minutebeachclean Day – May 17 th Clean Coasts are delighted to be holding Ireland’s first every National #2minutebeachclean day as part of Coca-Cola Clean Coasts Week. Our aim is to engage as many people as possible in this BIG IMPACT initiative. On May 17 th we are asking everyone who goes to the beach whether it’s for a surf, swim or walk to do their very own #2minutebeachclean. Take a snap of the litter collected and post your snap on instagram/twitter/facebook with the tags @cleancoasts #2minutebeachclean. It’s as easy as that and be in with a chance to win a Clean Coasts hoodie!

Marine Litter – A Work of Art! Pick up a piece of marine litter from Cork Harbour and have it included in an international work of art! This event is organised by Clean Coasts and Marlisco Ireland in collaboration with international artist Mandy Barker to highlight the environmental issue of marine litter. During Clean Coasts week (9 th- 18 th May) there will be a series of beach clean-ups organised around the Cork Harbour area. During these beach cleans, volunteers will be asked to find a piece of litter that they would like included in a series of contemporary photographic art works created by international artist Mandy Barker. Mandy’s pervious work has been exhibited worldwide and has featured in Time magazine. Mandy is undertaking a residency with the Sirius Art Centre in Cobh, County Cork during May. She will produce a series of work highlighting the marine litter issue and your litter item could be a part of her message!

To register a clean-up or find out more about Clean Coasts coastal celebration events please visit www.cleancoastsweek.ie

Marine Litter

Approximately 10 million tonnes of litter end up in the world's oceans and seas each year. The term "marine litter" covers a range of materials which have been deliberately discarded, or accidentally lost on shore or at sea, and it includes materials that are carried out to sea from land, rivers, drainage and sewerage systems, or the wind. Every piece of litter removed from the coast is a piece of litter that won't pollute our oceans or harm wildlife. In Ireland approximately 70% of the marine litter found is made of plastic. We must be cognisant of the fact that what we find on our beaches is not the full extent of the marine litter load in the environment. It is estimated that 70% of marine litter is on the seabed, 15% is floating in the water column and 15% is what we find on our shores.

Clean Coasts

Clean Coasts Ireland is owned and operated by the Environmental Education Unit of An Taisce – the National Trust for Ireland. It is funded by the Department of the Environment, Community & Local Government, Coca-Cola and Fáilte Ireland. It has been operating in Ireland for 11 years and engages 400 Clean Coasts groups and thousands of beach users. The Green Coast award is also part of the Clean Coasts programme and is an award for beaches that have excellent water quality but may not have the necessary built infrastructure to be eligible for the Blue Flag award. www.cleancoasts.org

Coca-Cola Coca-Cola is Ireland's largest manufacturer of premium non-alcoholic beverages and supplies a range of sparkling carbonated beverages, juices, mineral water and still drinks in the Irish marketplace. Overall, Coca-Cola employs 1900 across Ireland and Northern Ireland in locations including Dublin, Cork, Tuam, Ballina, Wexford, Athy, Drogheda, Lisburn and Omagh. Investing in the community and minimising environmental impact and ensuring resource sustainability in areas such water, energy and packaging is a key focus for Coca-Cola. Coca-Cola has also invested in an innovative green-tech Combined Heat and Power (CHP) plant at its Irish production facility in Lisburn - the first quad-generation CHP plant in Britain or Ireland.