An Taisce
The National Trust for Ireland

Energy  

Login   Register   facebook twitter                
      Protecting and preserving Ireland's heritage since 1948
  Search
 
 
 
An Taisce
 
 
 
Energy Home
 
 
 
Electricity
 
 
 
Fracking
 
 
 
Energy Links
 
 
 
History
 
 
 
Generation
 
 
 
Transmission/Distribution
 
 
 
Underground vs Overhead
 
 
News & Events Minimize

Energy Events

An Taisce Energy Events

There are no energy events this quarter

 _____________________

Energy Updates

March 9th 2011: Carbon Capture & Storage Institute Global Status Report

March 4th 2011: Domestic electricity deregulated

December 22nd 2010: Eirgrid publish their Grid 25 updates

December 21st 2010: ESB and Viridian finalise deal for Northern Ireland Electricity Network

___________________________

Energy Comments

March 2011: Irish Times Innovation Energy Policy Article

________________________

Energy Newsletters

Summer 2011

Spring 2011

Winter 2010

Autumn 2010

  
 
Energy Site Map Minimize
 
The Underground/Overground Debate Minimize

Overhead Wires vs Underground Cables

There is no doubt that this is an emotive subject that incites black and white opinions with very little grey.  An Taisce is attempting to occupy that 'grey area' by being as objective as possible.  This could very easily be construed as 'sitting on the fence' however, we believe that different solutions must be employed in different areas for different reasons. 

 

400kV Lines

There are 439kms of 400kV lines in the Republic of Ireland.  At the present time no country in the world has put the main ateries of their electricity Grids underground.  However, a trial project is being carried out in Denmark - parallel to their current over-head system as opposed to replacing it.  The result of the trial is not expected to be available for approximately 4 - 5 years.  Given the economic situation in which Ireland is mired presently, it would be folly to invest vast amounts of money in such embryonic technological systems.  It could result in the country being left with another white elephant along the lines of P-Pars Software and Electronic Voting Machines.  In this case, An Taisce believes that it is wise to bide our time until the results of the Danish trials are available.

275kV Lines

This voltage is used in Northern Ireland and in order to connect to their transmission system 42km of this line is currently in use at the Louth border.  None of this is undergrounded.

220kV Lines

220kV lines join with the 400kV lines to form the backbone of our Grid system.  There are 1,725kms of overhead wires at this voltage.  104kms are underground cables.

110kV Lines

3,905 kms of overhead wires at this voltage are currently in use.  53 kms of underground cables are in use however it is becoming more and more feasible to underground this voltage. 

  
 
An Taisce Energy Policy Note Minimize

 

An Taisce is aware of the visual impacts of overhead wires and supporting structures however, underground cables can cause irrepairable damage to the environment if laid cross-country.  Therefore if underground cables are to be used, An Taisce believes that where possible, they should be laid alongside the road network or on existing tracks.

  
 
 Copyright 2010 - 2011 by An Taisce   Terms Of Use  Privacy Statement