Skip to Content
  • Follow us
    Click here to setup your social networks
    Click here to setup your social networks
    Click here to setup your social networks
    Click here to setup your social networks
    Click here to setup your social networks
    Click here to setup your social networks
  • DONATE
  • MEMBERSHIP

An Taisce - The National Trust For Ireland
  • 0
    My Cart
  • 0
    Wishlist
  • Sign in
  • Home
  • About Us

    Our Mission

    Our Mission

    Who We Are

    Key Staff
    Board
    Council
    Local Associations



    History

    History

    Annual Reporting

    Annual Reports

  • Our Work

    School & University

    Green-Schools
    Green-Campus
    Globe Ireland
    Safe Routes to Schools
    LEAF — Learning About Ecosystems and Forests
    EU Projects

    Community

    Clean Coasts
    Climate Ambassadors
    National Spring Clean 

    Awards

    Blue Flag Award
    Green Coast Award
    Green Flag for Parks Award 

    Our Work

    Advocacy
    Submissions
    Policy Positions
    Properties in Trust
    Buildings At Risk 2025
  • News & Stories
    • News
    • Stories
    • Publications
    • Magazines
    • Events
  • Get Involved

    Donate

    Charitable Donation Scheme
    Donate

    Get Involved

    Other Ways To Give
    Volunteer
    Green Buildings

    Get Involved

    Membership
    Job Vacancies
    Legacies
  • Contact us
    • Contact Us
    • FAQs
An Taisce - The National Trust For Ireland
  • 0
  • 0
    • Home
    • About Us
    • Our Work
    • News & Stories
      • News
      • Stories
      • Publications
      • Magazines
      • Events
    • Get Involved
    • Contact us
      • Contact Us
      • FAQs
  • Follow us
    Click here to setup your social networks
    Click here to setup your social networks
    Click here to setup your social networks
    Click here to setup your social networks
    Click here to setup your social networks
    Click here to setup your social networks
  • Sign in
  • DONATE
  • MEMBERSHIP

An Taisce’s challenge of the contentious upgrade of the scenic N86 Dingle Route

  • All Blogs
  • News
  • An Taisce’s challenge of the contentious upgrade of the scenic N86 Dingle Route
  • 6 February 2015 by

    An Taisce is a charity that works to preserve and protect Ireland's natural and built heritage. We are an independent charitable voice for the environment and for heritage issues. An Taisce is not a government body, semi-state or agency.

    An Taisce has challenged the decision on this road development in the courts because we believe that An Board Pleanála did not correctly comply with and carry out the legal requirements laid down in Irish and EU Law for an Environmental Impact Assessment on the whole project. In this regard, it is also significant that the expert Inspector of An Bord Pleanála highlights An Taisce’s concerns as to how the project was being spilt into sections so as to preclude an overall environmental assessment (Note 5).

    Our laws provide, as a statutory right, provision for citizens and organisations to review decisions like this. In granting An Taisce permission for this challenge, the courts have already decided that there is an issue which needs to be fully heard and decided. The matter is now in front of the courts for them to decide on the legality or otherwise of the decision.

    To draw an analogy - consider a windfarm developer who decided to split up his project of 32 turbines into separate projects of 1 turbine each. Surely you would argue that the impacts of the all 32 turbines need to be considered and fully assessed as a whole.

    It is also worth noting that An Bord Pleanála itself originally decided that the exact same scheme represented an unjustifiable intrusion into the landscape of the Dingle Peninsula until this decision was judicially reviewed by Kerry County Council.

    A complete and thorough application of the Environmental Impact Assessment Directive requires the project as a whole be assessed. This decision and how it has been handled is not just important for this project but for many other projects.

    Since taking this challenge, An Taisce has received comments from people in Kerry and further afield, including tourists who've visited the area, welcoming our action. We have also received criticism and expressions of concern. To those we would say their frustration is more appropriately targeted at Kerry County Council and An Bord Pleanála whose actions have, in our view, compromised this project and how it has been assessed and failed to comply with the law.

    An Taisce wishes to see this matter dealt with promptly and will not be objecting to proposals to expedite its progress through the Courts so that it can be decided more swiftly in the interests of justice for all.

    ENDS

    For further information, please call:
    Charles Stanley-Smith, Communications, An Taisce Tel: +353 87 2411995
    email: publicaffairs@antaisce.org
    An Taisce The National Trust for Ireland
    www.antaisce.ie

    NOTES:

    1. An Bord Pleanála reference PL08.HA0048
    2. DIRECTIVE 2011/92/EU OF THE EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT AND OF THE COUNCIL of 13 December 2011 on the assessment of the effects of certain public and private projects on the environment, the EIA Directive”
    3. Permission was granted by the Board in November 2014, Board Ref PL08 .HA0048 following an earlier successful Judicial Review by Kerry County Council of an earlier decision in September 2013 by the Board to refuse the same scheme, Board Ref PL08 .HA0035, That court challenge resulted in the Board’s decision being quashed and remitted to the Board following on the judgement in April 2014 by Mr Justice Charleton. The Judgement determined in effect that the Board had not discharged its obligations under the Roads Act of 1993 as amended in making that initial decision which refused permission. The Board then in revisiting the scheme, reversed its decision and granted permission in November 2014.
    4. In October 2010, Kerry County Council, KCC made an application for direction to An Bord Pleanála in respect of the Environmental Impact Assessment requirements for a 32 KM scheme from Dingle to Tralee, Board Ref PL08. HD0019. KCC then decided to withdraw that given the availability of funding for a 4.2km component of the scheme which it advanced under the Planning and Development Act 2000 as amended and associated regulations and permitting it itself as a Local Authority own Development, without Assessment under the EIA directive. Within 2 months of withdrawing the application for direction for the 32 km route, it submitted an application to the Board for direction on EIA requirements for the remaining 28 km of the route, lying immediately either side of the 4.2 km stretch. ( Board Ref PL08. HD0024) The Board determined an EIS was required for the purposes of Environmental Impact Assessment. That 28 km stretch and how the Board has fulfilled its obligations under the EIA Directive is the subject of the current challenge. An Taisce argues the objectives of the EIA Directive have been compromised, that the Board has failed to fulfil its assessment obligations, and that the Board hasn’t adequately explained its reasons for coming to the decision and conclusions it has.
    5. The expert Inspector of An Bord Pleanála echoed An Taisce’s concerns as to how the project was being spilt into sections so as to preclude an overall environmental assessment. He noted in the strongest possible terms;

    “In the context of assessing the environmental impact of a proposed development, in my opinion the procedures being pursued here are unacceptable…. I must stress that the resulting outcome is that environmental impact assessment process is significantly diminished by this….The submitted EIS is flawed by taking out and separating from the assessment the stretch of road in the middle, which initially and correctly formed part of the overall scheme as originally referred to the Board. The EIS application and approval process is, thus, compromised.”

    in News
    CONSULTATION Deadline 3rd March National Inspection Plan for Domestic Waste Water Treatment Systems 2013

    Contact Us

    • Business Address
    • 5 Foster Place
    • Dublin 2, D02 V0P9
    • Ireland

    • Registered Address
    • Tailors' Hall, Back Lane
    • Dublin 8, D08 X2A3
    • Ireland

    • +353 1 454 1786
    • info@antaisce.org



    Links

    • Donate
    • Membership
    • Governance
    • Our Funders
    • Vacancies
    • Accessibility
    • Terms & Conditions
    • Privacy Policy
    • Cookies Policy
    • Sitemap
    • Login


    Follow us

    Social Media


    • © 2026 An Taisce - The National Trust for Ireland 
    • Registered in Ireland 12469 - Charity No. CHY4741 - Charity Regulator No. 20006358 - EU Transparency Register No. 275657497595-21
    Copyright © 2026 An Taisce - The National Trust for Ireland 
    Powered by Odoo - The #1 Open Source eCommerce