Skip to Content
  • Follow us
    Click here to setup your social networks
    Click here to setup your social networks
    Click here to setup your social networks
    Click here to setup your social networks
    Click here to setup your social networks
    Click here to setup your social networks
  • DONATE
  • MEMBERSHIP

An Taisce - The National Trust For Ireland
  • 0
    My Cart
  • 0
    Wishlist
  • Sign in
  • Home
  • About Us

    Our Mission

    Our Mission

    Who We Are

    Key Staff
    Board
    Council
    Local Associations



    History

    History

    Annual Reporting

    Annual Reports

  • Our Work

    School & University

    Green-Schools
    Green-Campus
    Globe Ireland
    Safe Routes to Schools
    LEAF — Learning About Ecosystems and Forests
    EU Projects

    Community

    Clean Coasts
    Climate Ambassadors
    National Spring Clean 

    Awards

    Blue Flag Award
    Green Coast Award
    Green Flag for Parks Award 

    Our Work

    Advocacy
    Submissions
    Policy Positions
    Properties in Trust
    Buildings At Risk 2025
  • News & Stories
    • News
    • Stories
    • Publications
    • Magazines
    • Events
  • Get Involved

    Donate

    Charitable Donation Scheme
    Donate

    Get Involved

    Other Ways To Give
    Volunteer
    Green Buildings

    Get Involved

    Membership
    Job Vacancies
    Legacies
  • Contact us
    • Contact Us
    • FAQs
An Taisce - The National Trust For Ireland
  • 0
  • 0
    • Home
    • About Us
    • Our Work
    • News & Stories
      • News
      • Stories
      • Publications
      • Magazines
      • Events
    • Get Involved
    • Contact us
      • Contact Us
      • FAQs
  • Follow us
    Click here to setup your social networks
    Click here to setup your social networks
    Click here to setup your social networks
    Click here to setup your social networks
    Click here to setup your social networks
    Click here to setup your social networks
  • Sign in
  • DONATE
  • MEMBERSHIP

Planning Bill Pre-Legislative Scrutiny Report makes many welcome recommendations but wide of the mark on access to justice

  • All Blogs
  • News
  • Planning Bill Pre-Legislative Scrutiny Report makes many welcome recommendations but wide of the mark on access to justice
  • 3 May 2023 by

    The Government must very seriously re-think its approach to its review of the planning legislation. The need for significant revision and further detailed consideration of the new Planning Bill is reflected in the pre-legislative scrutiny (PLS) report which was published Thursday morning by the Joint Oireachtas Committee on Housing, Local Government and Heritage. Many of the report’s 153 recommendations are very welcome, however, they don’t resolve the most significant and controversial part of the draft bill relating to the legally problematic changes to the judicial review provisions.

    An Taisce very much welcomes the PLS Report’s strong emphasis on the need for sufficient time for extensive scrutiny of the final bill. We are also very pleased to see the Report echo our calls for a period of public consultation on the bill as well as the publication of an explanatory memo and evidence base for the changes and a Regulatory Impact Assessment. None of these have been published by the Department, which has seriously hampered the evaluation of the bill to date. 

    However, the Report’s approach to the changes to the judicial review rules has not sufficiently addressed the myriad of problems that these changes will cause. 

    Phoebe Duvall, Planning and Environmental Policy Officer with An Taisce said:

    “Multiple, very well-informed groups expressed serious concerns to the Committee about the delays, dysfunction and additional legal cases that will result from these changes, and recommended that the existing provisions are retained, as they currently function well.

    “However, instead of recommending that the judicial review changes be rejected and the current provisions be reinstated, the Report takes a piecemeal approach and fails to comprehensively address the substance of the legal problems. While the 14 recommendations on access to justice do identify some of the serious issues with the provisions, they leave open multiple avenues for more delay and litigation. This is entirely contrary to the bill’s objective to increase efficiency and speed in the planning system. The report also has not adequately addressed the complete lack of justification for the proposed changes.”

    “The bill’s retrograde approach to judicial review raises very serious issues of compliance with the Aarhus Convention on access to justice, and the PLS report rightly recommended that these provisions be reviewed against the Convention. As the Minister with responsibility for Aarhus compliance, we are calling on Minister Eamon Ryan to ensure that this legislation upholds the fundamental public right to access justice.”

    “We can’t overstate the enormity of the bill’s implications for our communities and our environment. It’s also a once in a generation opportunity to get our planning laws right so we can urgently and effectively address the crises we face in housing, climate, energy, etc. But the bill as it stands right now will fall far short of achieving that.”



    ENDS



    Contact: Phoebe Duvall, Planning and Environmental Policy Officer, An Taisce: planning@antaisce.org




    in News
    Immediate and Transformative Action Needed to Stay Below 1.5°C

    Contact Us

    • Business Address
    • 5 Foster Place
    • Dublin 2, D02 V0P9
    • Ireland

    • Registered Address
    • Tailors' Hall, Back Lane
    • Dublin 8, D08 X2A3
    • Ireland

    • +353 1 454 1786
    • info@antaisce.org



    Links

    • Donate
    • Membership
    • Governance
    • Our Funders
    • Vacancies
    • Accessibility
    • Terms & Conditions
    • Privacy Policy
    • Cookies Policy
    • Sitemap
    • Login


    Follow us

    Social Media


    • © 2026 An Taisce - The National Trust for Ireland 
    • Registered in Ireland 12469 - Charity No. CHY4741 - Charity Regulator No. 20006358 - EU Transparency Register No. 275657497595-21
    Copyright © 2026 An Taisce - The National Trust for Ireland 
    Powered by Odoo - The #1 Open Source eCommerce