Pre-budget statement from An Taisce Climate Committee
You can download the press release via this link.
An Taisce calls stop on this climate madness
Ireland is subsidising fossil fuels up to five times the EU average. It is likely to account for 6 billion euro this year. There are alternatives that can meet climate goals and social needs.
At COP26 in Glasgow and again at COP28 in Dubai, Ireland, as part of the EU commitment, agreed to accelerate the phase-out of “inefficient” fossil fuel subsidies. These are defined as any interventions that artificially lower coal, oil, or fossil gas prices, encourage wasteful energy consumption, or otherwise distort markets in favour of fossil fuels. The definition excludes carefully targeted and temporary supports, designed to help low-income households and vulnerable businesses access basic energy needs, where non-fossil alternatives are not immediately available. However recent Irish government measures to moderate fossil fuel costs have been across the board, with no meaningful targeting, credible time limits or concrete plans to quickly end underlying fossil fuel dependencies. They are thus properly regarded as adding to our already very high level of fossil fuel subsidisation.
This flies in the face of our urgent need to limit climate change (by phasing out fossil fuel use completely and rapidly), undermines our public finances, artificially obscures the severity of our predicament, and diverts funding away from urgently needed positive interventions to ensure all citizens have affordable access to a sufficient level of clean energy services (heating, transport etc.).
The CSO estimated that total fossil fuel subsidies in Ireland in 2024 were €4.7 billion. Blanket measures affecting motor fuels were announced in June 2026 that added €750M in subsidies and in July a further €270M. The total fossil fuel subsidy figure for 2026 may well now be more than €6 billion. Total fossil fuel subsidies across the EU in 2023 amounted to €111 billion. Thus, on a per capita basis, Ireland is subsidising fossil fuels at a rate up to 5 times the EU average.
For comparative purposes the estimated cost of the new Children’s Hospital is €2.24 billion and the total Education Budget for 2026 is €13.5 billion.
The total budget allocated to SEAI in 2026 for grants for solar energy, retrofits etc was €640M i.e. around only 10% of what has been spent on fossil fuel subsidies. The loss of carbon tax revenue would diminish this budget further and exacerbate the already unsustainable fiscal balance in favour of continued fossil fuel dependency.
This is all, of course, before any consideration of the looming compliance costs for the Irish exchequer when – according to current government plans – it falls far short of its agreed EU 2030 climate obligations.
At a time when Ireland is presiding over EU efforts to support and uphold undertakings made at various COPs, it is regrettable that doubling down on inefficient subsidies and withdrawing taxpayer funds from other climate-related area will be demonstrated at COP31 and raise serious questions concerning the credibility of Irish ambition to support either the EU or UNFCCC’s obligations.
The Government argument seems to be that "there is no alternative": that the short-term pressure of general energy affordability must “pragmatically” override all attempts at more prudent, strategic, action. The An Taisce position, however, is that nothing could be further from the truth: alternatives exist and simply demand Government will.
In particular, fossil fuel supports can and should be tightly targeted to those – primarily households (not businesses) who would otherwise face material energy poverty. In the context of transport, this means first and foremost ensuring access to public transport, for example via targeted Leap card credits, co-ordinated with emergency expansion in service frequency and coverage and the reversal of the recent entirely misguided increase in general transport fares. It also acknowledging genuine needs for much less energy efficient private motor transport and therefore allowing an appropriate level of exchange between public transport credit and discounts on motor fuel purchase. Similar credits, targeted and capped, could be offered for home heating for all energy types. This should be integrated with a programme to ensure all such eligible households are transitioned off fossil fuel heating as quickly as possible and certainly within the tenure of the current Government.
Alternatively, similar benefits might be achieved with less administrative complexity by a system that issues universal credits for energy use (capped at a level sufficient for healthy living) funded with appropriately progressive taxation measures (thus relying on the established targeting role of taxation).
Looking even slightly beyond our immediate crisis of fossil energy cost, the medium-term logic of the emergency measures outlined above may be best addressed by an integrated, society-wide, system of Tradeable Emissions Quotas (or TEQs [1, 2, 3]), covering all households, businesses and public bodies. The architecture of such a system has already been extremely well studied, with some pilot-scale deployments. It is particularly designed to ensure fair and just effort sharing by all while harnessing bottom-up creativity and innovation in building a truly sustainable future. There is a real opportunity for Ireland to turn the current crisis into an opportunity by leading the world in rolling out such a national level TEQs system.
What is needed now are not alternatives to more fossil fuel subsidies but political leadership to implement transformational change – and protect our shared future
Terri Morrissey, Chair, An Taisce.
How much longer must we make do instead with platitudes and mis-guided, unjust, half-measures, when just and effective alternatives are already on the drawing board, ready to be implemented?
Professor Barry McMullin, An Taisce Climate Committee.
References:
[1] TEQs, at a glance, Fleming Policy Centre (UK).
https://www.flemingpolicycentre.org.uk/teqs/
[2] Reconciling scientific reality with realpolitik: moving beyond carbon pricing to TEQs – an integrated, economy-wide emissions cap. Chamberlin, Maxey & Hurth, Carbon Management (2014) 5(4), 411–427.
https://www.flemingpolicycentre.org.uk/Reconciling%20scientific%20reality%20with%20realpolitik.pdf
[3] TEQs: Empowering Citizens for Radical Climate Action, Submission to the Irish Citizens’ Assembly, Professor Barry McMullin (DCU), 2017
https://www.postcarbonireland.org/etc/2017/Citizens-Assembly-Climate-Action-2017-08-11-BMcM-Full.pdf