Skip to Content
  • Follow us
    Click here to setup your social networks
    Click here to setup your social networks
    Click here to setup your social networks
    Click here to setup your social networks
    Click here to setup your social networks
    Click here to setup your social networks
  • DONATE
  • MEMBERSHIP

An Taisce - The National Trust For Ireland
  • 0
    My Cart
  • 0
    Wishlist
  • Sign in
  • Home
  • About Us

    Our Mission

    Our Mission

    Who We Are

    Key Staff
    Board
    Council
    Local Associations



    History

    History

    Annual Reporting

    Annual Reports

  • Our Work

    School & University

    Green-Schools
    Green-Campus
    Globe Ireland
    Safe Routes to Schools
    LEAF — Learning About Ecosystems and Forests
    EU Projects

    Community

    Clean Coasts
    Climate Ambassadors
    National Spring Clean 

    Awards

    Blue Flag Award
    Green Coast Award
    Green Flag for Parks Award 

    Our Work

    Advocacy
    Submissions
    Policy Positions
    Properties in Trust
    Buildings At Risk 2025
  • News & Stories
    • News
    • Stories
    • Publications
    • Magazines
    • Events
  • Get Involved

    Donate

    Charitable Donation Scheme
    Donate

    Get Involved

    Other Ways To Give
    Volunteer
    Green Buildings

    Get Involved

    Membership
    Job Vacancies
    Legacies
  • Contact us
    • Contact Us
    • FAQs
An Taisce - The National Trust For Ireland
  • 0
  • 0
    • Home
    • About Us
    • Our Work
    • News & Stories
      • News
      • Stories
      • Publications
      • Magazines
      • Events
    • Get Involved
    • Contact us
      • Contact Us
      • FAQs
  • Follow us
    Click here to setup your social networks
    Click here to setup your social networks
    Click here to setup your social networks
    Click here to setup your social networks
    Click here to setup your social networks
    Click here to setup your social networks
  • Sign in
  • DONATE
  • MEMBERSHIP

Explainer: What is the EPA nitrates derogation 'Red Map'?

  • All Blogs
  • Stories
  • Explainer: What is the EPA nitrates derogation 'Red Map'?
  • 18 July 2023 by

    What is the Derogation? 

    The Nitrates Directive came into force in 1991. Its objective is to protect water quality from agricultural pollution and to promote the use of good farming practices. Despite this, nearly half of our rivers (47%) and a third of lakes are failing to meet their environmental quality standards for nutrients, with serious consequences for the health of Irish waters. 

    The Nitrates Derogation is a licence to spread more organic nitrogen per hectare on land than is routinely permitted under the Nitrates Directive. According to the text of the Directive, organic Nitrogen is livestock manure applied to the land each year, including by the animals themselves.  

     

    Text from Annex III of the Nitrates Directive 

    As a member state, Ireland applies to Europe for this every 4 years, based on the argument that we have a long growing season, our fields can absorb it, and that it will not put water quality at risk. Once granted by the European Commission to the Irish government, Irish farmers in turn apply annually to the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine for a derogation licence for their farms.  

    While the Nitrates Directive allows for the granting of derogations, it does so on the proviso that the derogation does not undermine the objective of that Directive, which is to reduce and prevent water pollution as a result of agriculture. Under normal circumstances, a landowner is not allowed to apply more than 170 kilograms of organic nitrogen per hectare per year on their land, however if you are operating under a derogation licence you can lawfully spread up to 250 kilograms of organic nitrogen per hectare per year on your land.  Landowners farming under a derogation are subject to stricter regulation, such as an obligation to use low emission slurry spreading and demonstrating sufficient capacity for slurry storage. 

    What is happening with the Derogation?
    When Ireland was granted a derogation in April of 2022, the Commission put in a condition
    that an interim water quality review be carried out in 2023, and that in areas where water
    quality criteria, determined by the Commission, have not been achieved then additional
    measures must be put in place by January 2024. This interim water quality report was
    conducted by the EPA and is published here. There were four pollution criteria included in
    the derogation decision, two of which are based on the nitrate concentrations in water, and
    two on eutrophication. The eutrophication assessment is based on the nutrient status- that
    is, if nitrate and phosphate are elevated, and on biological indicators such as plants and
    invertebrates. The EPA laid out their methodology for monitoring water quality and nutrient
    status in this document.

    What is the EPA ‘Red Map’?
    Based on these criteria, determined from a particular sampling network, the EPA produced a
    map, the ‘Red Map’, indicating where additional measures are required. Anywhere within the
    Red Area is deemed to need additional measures according to the derogation decision,
    including a reduction in the maximum amount of nitrogen that can be spread on derogation
    farms, reduced from 250 kilograms of nitrogen per hectare per year, to 220 kilograms of
    nitrogen per hectare per year.

    EPA ‘Red Map’

    Why does the map look strange?
    You may logically ask why the map is not coloured in some areas which, based on previous
    EPA water quality reports, are clearly in need of additional measures when it comes to water
    quality. For example, the Slaney river was previously reported to have more than 50%
    excess nitrogen, yet a large part of its catchment doesn’t seem to require additional
    measures. How does this make sense?

    The reason is largely due to the sampling network used. The EPA have a very extensive
    sampling network which they use for their Water Framework Directive monitoring. However,
    for the purposes of the Nitrates Directive the EPA are only required to use a subset of this
    sampling network- as laid out in Article 12 of the Nitrates Directive. This is what the EPA are
    mandated to do. The maps below highlight the difference between the sampling networks.
    The surveillance monitoring network, which was used to create the Red Map, is used for
    reporting for the Nitrates Directive, and represents a proportion of representative
    waterbodies, sampled frequently. The Operational Network is sampled less frequently but is
    more extensive.

    In a nutshell, some of the areas in the Red Map are not included solely because there was
    no representative sampling point for that area.

     

    Does this mean the EPA data is invalid?
    In a word, no. The EPA consistently produce high quality data, based on robust
    water/catchment science which we can fully depend on. The EPA themselves acknowledge
    that the dataset they are obliged to use for the purposes of reporting on the Nitrates
    Directive is more limited spatially than what they use for the Water Framework Directive
    reporting, as a result of the former being a much older Directive, and not fully reflecting the
    more modern catchment-based approach. The below map, Map 9 from their water quality
    report, represents their most comprehensive data, where they clearly overlay where
    agricultural measures need to be targeted, based on their full operational data set.

    EPA Map 9

    Where do we go from here?
    Views have been expressed within the agri-media that reducing the derogation limit within
    those Red areas would achieve nothing for water quality. This is categorically untrue, any
    reduction in the load of nitrogen onto catchments with excess nitrogen will benefit water
    quality, with variability in efficacy based on local factors. However, for the best outcomes
    water quality measures should be targeted as indicated on the map above, in Map 9.

    It is now up to the Irish Government to chart a path forward, based on the results and the
    requirements of the Commission Decision. A critical point to note is that the Irish
    Government is fully entitled to rely on additional information, so there is nothing stopping
    them from implementing additional measures, and additional reductions in nitrate limits, in
    the necessary areas as indicated by the EPA in their more comprehensive data. That is,
    while Ireland is legally required by the derogation decision to reduce the derogation limit in
    those Red areas, they are free to propose additional measures both within and outside of
    those areas if they believe this will lead to improvements in water quality, for example more
    stringent nutrient management plans, or changes to manure spreading.

    So, for those attesting that the EPA Red Map is ‘nonsensical’ and that the Commission are
    forcing Ireland to only use this data, the reality is that Irish Government can choose what                                                            additional data to rely on, to complement what the EPA have already produced to fulfil the
    requirement of the derogation decision. More comprehensive data is available from the EPA,
    as outlined above, and it could and should be used in charting a way forward for this.

    Logically, based on the more detailed monitoring by the EPA, and recent nitrate pollution
    trends, large swathes of Cork, Waterford and Wexford should also be included in the Red
    Map. Additionally, there are areas up north, for example in Roscommon, which according to
    the EPA’s best science, won’t benefit as much from nitrate reduction measures, as
    phosphate is the issue in many of these areas. It is now up to the Irish Government to
    present that argument to the Commision, in a well-formulated plan, based on the full picture
    provided by all of the data produced by the EPA.

    Whatever path is chosen, taking action to tackle water quality is no longer optional, and the
    derogation decision is legally binding. Any delay, or lack of compliance will do nothing to
    further Ireland’s chances of securing a future derogation, if that is what the Irish
    Government intends to do in 2026. We’ve reached a critical point in tackling water quality in
    Ireland, and given recent trends over the past decade we need ambitious and far-reaching
    actions to address water pollution.

    in Stories
    Will You Meet Me on Clare Island?

    Contact Us

    • Business Address
    • 5 Foster Place
    • Dublin 2, D02 V0P9
    • Ireland

    • Registered Address
    • Tailors' Hall, Back Lane
    • Dublin 8, D08 X2A3
    • Ireland

    • +353 1 454 1786
    • info@antaisce.org



    Links

    • Donate
    • Membership
    • Governance
    • Our Funders
    • Vacancies
    • Accessibility
    • Terms & Conditions
    • Privacy Policy
    • Cookies Policy
    • Sitemap
    • Login


    Follow us

    Social Media


    • © 2026 An Taisce - The National Trust for Ireland 
    • Registered in Ireland 12469 - Charity No. CHY4741 - Charity Regulator No. 20006358 - EU Transparency Register No. 275657497595-21
    Copyright © 2026 An Taisce - The National Trust for Ireland 
    Powered by Odoo - The #1 Open Source eCommerce