Skip to Content
  • Follow us
    Click here to setup your social networks
    Click here to setup your social networks
    Click here to setup your social networks
    Click here to setup your social networks
    Click here to setup your social networks
    Click here to setup your social networks
  • DONATE
  • MEMBERSHIP

An Taisce - The National Trust For Ireland
  • 0
    My Cart
  • 0
    Wishlist
  • Sign in
  • Home
  • About Us

    Our Mission

    Our Mission

    Who We Are

    Key Staff
    Board
    Council
    Local Associations



    History

    History

    Annual Reporting

    Annual Reports

  • Our Work

    School & University

    Green-Schools
    Green-Campus
    Globe Ireland
    Safe Routes to Schools
    LEAF — Learning About Ecosystems and Forests
    EU Projects

    Community

    Clean Coasts
    Climate Ambassadors
    National Spring Clean 

    Awards

    Blue Flag Award
    Green Coast Award
    Green Flag for Parks Award 

    Our Work

    Advocacy
    Submissions
    Policy Positions
    Properties in Trust
    Buildings At Risk 2025
  • News & Stories
    • News
    • Stories
    • Publications
    • Magazines
    • Events
  • Get Involved

    Donate

    Charitable Donation Scheme
    Donate

    Get Involved

    Other Ways To Give
    Volunteer
    Green Buildings

    Get Involved

    Membership
    Job Vacancies
    Legacies
  • Contact us
    • Contact Us
    • FAQs
An Taisce - The National Trust For Ireland
  • 0
  • 0
    • Home
    • About Us
    • Our Work
    • News & Stories
      • News
      • Stories
      • Publications
      • Magazines
      • Events
    • Get Involved
    • Contact us
      • Contact Us
      • FAQs
  • Follow us
    Click here to setup your social networks
    Click here to setup your social networks
    Click here to setup your social networks
    Click here to setup your social networks
    Click here to setup your social networks
    Click here to setup your social networks
  • Sign in
  • DONATE
  • MEMBERSHIP

Loss and Damage: Talking the Talk but not Walking the Walk at COP27

  • All Blogs
  • Stories
  • Loss and Damage: Talking the Talk but not Walking the Walk at COP27
  • 17 July 2022 by

    Classical economists have consistently failed to get to grips with the cost of climate change. The
    methodologies of classical economics cannot be used effectively to quantify the losses and damages
    involved. Where in geographical terms do the parameters of losses and damage begin and end? How
    should indirect events such as fires be incorporated? How should ‘slow onset’ events such as
    droughts or biodiversity losses be quantified? How should ‘natural’ catastrophes be distinguished
    from those driven by anthropogenic influences? Over what time scale should damage costs be
    considered? These are just some of the issues that have bedevilled attempts to persuade the
    developed world that financial recompense on a large scale is a matter of climate justice due to the
    global south for the climate extremes they increasingly suffer.


    One of the earliest attempts to price the costs of climate change came from William Nordhaus, a
    winner of the Nobel Memorial Prize in Economic Sciences in 2018. As far back as the 1990s he was
    estimating that a warming of 2.5 o C would result in a loss of income 1-1.5%. This was astonishingly
    low, and built on assumptions that a large part of economic activity happened indoors and would be
    minimally affected by climate change. Such are the breathtaking assumptions that sometimes
    underpin economic models! Even at the time it was pointed out to him by climate scientists that
    taking a wider perspective would result in estimates 20-30 times higher. We now know just how
    much in error these early estimates were, and can appreciate how much they hindered political
    decision making. Last year the respected Moody’s Analytics estimated that a warming of even 2 o C
    would cause economic losses of €66 trillion while a recent study by Oxfam and Swiss Re estimated
    that the cost of a 2.6 o C warming would be 13.9% each year. Even today, we hear a lot about the cost
    of taking action to combat climate change, but relatively little about the cost of inaction.


    It might be logical to surmise that insurance companies were wise to the risks involved in insuring
    properties vulnerable to a regime of increasing extremes, and they were aware of the potential for
    catastrophic losses that might result for them. It might be logical to assume that they would be in
    the forefront of policies to tackle climate change and be applying pressure to decision makers to
    reduce emissions. But this hasn’t happened and low premium insurance is still available in areas of
    known risk. Even in Ireland, insurance for houses recently built in known flood risk areas is possible.
    Why this occurred is not clear, but a large part of the explanation is the ability of insurance
    companies to outsource their risk to private investors willing to gamble on an event not occurring in
    a particular year. The availability of national safety nets guaranteed by governments also helped.
    Taking a chance that the 1-in-50 year event won’t happen in 2022 is a fair investment gamble for
    some. This has echoes of course of the way the global banking crisis emerged from the offloading of
    risky mortgages at the end of the first decade of this century.


    Ultimately even this strategy has its limits. The fires in California in 2018 cost the insurance industry
    just under €12 billion, a fraction of what Hurricanes Andrew or Sandy cost and a tenth of what
    Hurricane Katrina cost. The realisation that risks can’t ultimately be avoided is slowly sinking in. This
    has been especially clear in recent years. As climate change has increasingly come home to roost in
    the developed world, the issues surrounding loss and damage have moved centre stage. The
    arguments made by developing countries, where loss of life rather than loss of property is the main
    concern are now better appreciated.


    ‘Loss and damage’ is the general term used in UN climate negotiations to refer to impacts of climate
    change that exceed the adaptive capacity of affected countries, especially when this capacity is limited by finances. Of course, for communities, non-economic losses are the most important: the
    loss of life, the loss of home places, even the loss of culture that potentially faces the Small Island
    Developing States. In many ways, loss and damage is the third leg of the stool, after mitigation and
    adaptation, that must be integrated into climate action. This was recognised in the Paris Agreement
    and climate finance directing flows from the global north to the global south is in part a
    consequence of this. But institutionalising a response at an international scale has foundered due to
    the difficulties in answering the questions raised in the first paragraph above.


    The emergence of new techniques in climate science offer an opportunity to address many of the
    questions concerned. Attribution is the tool that can unlock the percentage contribution humans
    have made to an individual extreme event occurring. This has been facilitated by the exponential
    growth in computing power that enables climate models to be run multiple times. One series of runs
    can be made with the greenhouse gases at pre industrial levels to ascertain how likely an event
    would be under ‘natural’ conditions. A second series then is run with the greenhouse gases added as
    they increased over time. By comparing the outputs it is possible to estimate how much more likely
    a given event is due to human interference with the atmosphere. So for example the floods in
    Germany, Belgium and the Netherlands this time last year were 9 times more likely, the heatwave in
    Siberia in 2020 10-100 times more likely, the 2019 heatwave in France 10 times more likely etc.
    When the modelling is done for this year’s heatwave in Spain and France a similar figure is likely to
    emerge.


    If the damage cost is known and the human contribution can be estimated, the culprits can be
    levied. This is the ultimate objective for the global south, forcing the developed world to be
    accountable in financial terms for the climate change burden inflicted on the global south. Naturally,
    this is not going to be an easy task! Slow onset events such as desertification, biodiversity losses,
    land and forest degradation, rising sea levels, ocean acidification etc are particularly problematical,
    not to mention the cultural and population displacement issues involved.

     
    At the Glasgow COP26 only limited progress was made in addressing Loss and Damage. The
    resistance of the developed world was again demonstrated. As a compromise, a 2-year plan, the
    Glasgow Dialogue, was established to chart the way ahead in funding terms. Some funding was
    provided to operationalise a scheme, the Santiago Network, to help developing countries with the
    technicalities of coping with loss and damage issues. Minister Ryan announced that Ireland would
    contribute €5 million to support this technical network. In addition, the Taoiseach committed to
    raising Ireland’s climate finance contribution to reach €225 million per annum by 2025. But for
    some of the world’s big polluters the chequebooks remain tightly closed. There is no doubt but that
    Loss and damage will be the main focus of COP27 in November. However, given the health, war and
    economic issues that have characterised the past year, optimism that solidarity with the countries
    vulnerable to climate-change related disasters will be reflected in a comprehensive system of
    financial transfers must be limited.

    in Stories
    Into the West...On a Greenway

    Contact Us

    • Business Address
    • 5 Foster Place
    • Dublin 2, D02 V0P9
    • Ireland

    • Registered Address
    • Tailors' Hall, Back Lane
    • Dublin 8, D08 X2A3
    • Ireland

    • +353 1 454 1786
    • info@antaisce.org



    Links

    • Donate
    • Membership
    • Governance
    • Our Funders
    • Vacancies
    • Accessibility
    • Terms & Conditions
    • Privacy Policy
    • Cookies Policy
    • Sitemap
    • Login


    Follow us

    Social Media


    • © 2026 An Taisce - The National Trust for Ireland 
    • Registered in Ireland 12469 - Charity No. CHY4741 - Charity Regulator No. 20006358 - EU Transparency Register No. 275657497595-21
    Copyright © 2026 An Taisce - The National Trust for Ireland 
    Powered by Odoo - The #1 Open Source eCommerce