Full submission available via this link.
Extract:
An Taisce wish to submit the following in relation to the current application for the renewal of the Industrial Emissions Licence of Aughinish Alumina. Compliance with the conditions of the existing EPA license(s) for the site should be evaluated as a preliminary matter.
In the first instance, we would highlight an issue with the accessibility of the Environmental Impact Assessment. The consultation period in advance of the Proposed Determination is open, and yet not all of the EIA documentation was made available on the EPA website – only the main EIAR text is available, not the appendices upon which the main EIAR relies.
We consider that the Human Health Assessment (HHA) has not fully considered the potential for chronic arsenic (As) exposure in the affected population. This assessment is based on several factors: (i) arsenic is commonly present in trace but variable concentrations in lateritic bauxites; (ii) under the highly alkaline conditions typical of Bayer- process residues, arsenic may be present as arsenate species with potential mobility in porewater; and (iii) as one of the principal exposure pathway described—airborne dusting of fine particulate material—provides a plausible route for repeated low-dose exposure via inhalation and subsequent ingestion of deposited material.
In addition, arsenic volatilization and subsequent atmospheric transport and re-absorption cannot be fully excluded as a complementary exposure mechanism contributing to chronic intoxication, particularly in the presence of alkaline industrial residues and variable redox conditions in fine particulate emissions.
We raise the issue that there has been no follow up biomonitoring study among the affected population since blood samples from the four-year animal and human health investigation went missing in the late 1990s.
The potential risks to water quality as a result of bauxite and salt cake disposal, particularly from a failure of containment in the Bauxite Residual Disposal Area (BRDA), stem from various pathways: by air (dusting); by seepage through the unlined areas or potential compromised lining of the BRDA; by flooding or other extreme climate events; or by BRDA breach or complete failure. Given the site’s location on the shore of the Lower Shannon Estuary, which includes the Lower River Shannon SAC (site code: 002165), River Shannon and River Fergus Estuaries SPA (site code: 004077) and the Inner Shannon Estuary - South Shore pNHA (site code: 000435), the potential impacts must be fully addressed by the EPA to ensure compliance with the Environmental Impact Assessment Directive, Habitats and Birds Directives, Water Framework Directive and Groundwater Directive.
Full submission available via this link.